On the Market for a New Saddle? Here’s Where to Start

Buying a saddle is one of the most expensive and intimidating purchases you’ll make as a rider. Get it right and you’ll have a comfortable, well-fitting saddle that lasts years. Get it wrong and you’re looking at a sore horse, an uncomfortable ride, and a very expensive lesson. Here’s everything you need to know before you start shopping.

Fit Comes First — Always

The single most important thing about a saddle is how it fits your horse. Not how it looks, not the brand name, not the colour. Fit. A beautifully crafted £2,000 leather saddle that doesn’t fit your horse is worse than a £400 synthetic one that does.

Before you buy anything, get your horse assessed by a qualified saddle fitter. Many will do this for free if you’re buying through them. They’ll measure your horse’s back, assess the wither height and shape, and identify any asymmetries that need accommodating. This step is non-negotiable.

Understanding Tree Widths

The tree is the internal frame of the saddle, and its width determines how the saddle sits on your horse’s back. Common tree widths include narrow, medium, medium-wide, wide, and extra-wide. Getting this right is crucial:

• Too narrow: The saddle will pinch the withers, cause pressure points, and restrict movement
• Too wide: The saddle will sit too low on the withers, rock side to side, and distribute weight unevenly
• Just right: Even contact across the panels, clearance over the withers, and freedom of movement through the shoulders

Some brands like Thorowgood offer changeable gullet systems, which can be a great option if your horse’s shape changes with fitness.

Leather vs Synthetic

This used to be simple — leather was better, end of. But modern synthetics have closed the gap considerably.

Leather offers a superior feel, better grip, and develops a beautiful patina over time. It moulds to both horse and rider. But it requires regular conditioning, is heavier, and costs significantly more.

Synthetic saddles are lighter, easier to clean, more affordable, and often come with adjustable features like changeable gullets. The trade-off is a less premium feel and they won’t last as long as a well-maintained leather saddle.

For a first saddle or a budget purchase, synthetic is a smart choice. For a long-term investment, leather is hard to beat.

Panel Types

Saddle panels are the cushioned pads on the underside that distribute your weight across the horse’s back. The main types are:

• Wool-flocked: Traditional, adjustable by a saddler, offers a custom fit. The gold standard but requires regular reflocking.
• Foam: Consistent shape, lower maintenance, but can’t be as precisely adjusted. Common on synthetic saddles.
• Air: Used in some modern designs for even weight distribution. Innovative but less proven long-term.

Budgeting Realistically

Saddle prices range enormously. Here’s a rough guide:

• £300–£600: Entry-level synthetic saddles. Good for everyday riding and learning.
• £600–£1,200: Quality synthetic or entry-level leather saddles. A solid mid-range option.
• £1,200–£2,500: Quality leather saddles from established brands. Expect excellent craftsmanship.
• £2,500+: Premium and custom-made saddles. For serious competitors or those who want the very best.

Don’t forget to budget for a saddle fitting (£40–£80), a good saddle pad, and annual check-ups.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Buying without a fitting: The number one mistake. Always get fitted.
• Buying for looks: That Instagram-worthy saddle means nothing if it doesn’t fit.
• Ignoring the rider: The saddle needs to fit you too. Seat size matters.
• Skipping the trial: Always try before you buy. Most reputable sellers offer trial periods.
• Forgetting maintenance: Leather needs conditioning. Synthetics need cleaning. Budget time for care.

Our Recommendation

Start with a professional fitting, set a realistic budget, and don’t rush. A well-fitting £500 saddle will always outperform a badly-fitting £2,000 one. Check out our Thorowgood T8 review for an excellent entry-level option.